Review guidelines

Describe supervision clearly and protect people.

Approved
On this page

Use your own experience

Explain what helped you and what was difficult. Describe concrete working practices without claiming to speak for everyone. Do not guess motives, copy another review or submit repeated reviews through different accounts.

Protect identities

Leave out names of students, contact details, exact dates, small-group counts and distinctive stories that identify people. A reviewer should not have to reveal who they are to be heard.

Before publication

A moderator checks every review and edit. Public text, ratings and counts require 3 published reviews. A mentoring style is a matter of fit, not a score of personal worth.

Corrections and concerns

Edit or withdraw your own review from My reviews. Report identifying information, abuse or spam on a published review. Use Support for a correction or a moderation appeal; keep its reference.